What is an RRSP, TFSA, FHSA, RESP?

Ok so we want to buy these index fund things. Where do we do that? Well most banks offer a trading platform, but so too do questrade and wealthsimple (and if you use my referral code we both get bonuses: wealthsimple.com/invite/0DQX5A)  At these places you can have a normal account (questrade calls this a margin account - we won't talk about what trading on margin is. That's for later and maybe even then only an ok idea).

So you put \$1000 in this trading account. With the money you buy shares of an index fund, let's say vun.to that owns as underlying assets most of the American economy. Let's say for simplicity you bought 10 shares at \$100 each. 2 things happen over time:

(1) the underlying companies make profits that they give to the owners of the companies (you). The index fund adds all these dividends up and gives them to you and every one else that owns shares of that index fund. This happens like... every 3 months or something depending on the fund. Yay! your money has made you money. This money gets deposited into your account.

However, you have just made income in Canada and as such you have to pay income tax on it. Less yay. Although, lucky you that you are so abundant that your money is making money and you can donate to Canada. Canada then builds you some nice roads to drive on and schools for your kids and Canada is relatively less corrupt than almost anywhere in the world. 

(2) The value of your shares goes up to $110 each. You decide to sell them and now you have $1100 (minus a transaction fee). Your capital has gained value. Yay! When you make money like this in Canada you pay capital gains tax. Less yay, but you know, Canada is mostly doing good things with that money (they are not, for instance, supporting a trillion dollar military or just absconding with our money like in less stable places). And so you donate to Canada and Canada supports some of those folks in need that are not so fortunate as you. 

Registered accounts all have weirder implications for taxes and they are all there to make things easier for you. Canada wants you to save and invest so it helps you to plan for retirement, buying a house, sending your kids to university and just generally encourages you to invest.

----------------

Tax-Free Savings Account (TFSA)

This is the easiest one to understand. Instead of just having money in your bank account you can open one of these things. In this account you can have money, but you can also trade that money for index funds (as well as other stuff that we're not gonna buy.)

When either scenario (1) or (2) happen in a TFSA Canada doesn't tax you. You can make all the dividends and capital gains you want in a TFSA and you don't pay tax. That's a pretty good deal. There's a limit on how much you can put into your TFSA. This amount goes up steadily year after year. Your notice of assessment from last year should tell you how much you're allowed to put in.

If you doubled your money in your TFSA with some happy investments, then the room in your TFSA has also grown.

----------------
Registered Retirement Savings Account (RRSP)

This is a little weirder to understand. When you put money into your RRSP it's as if you didn't need to pay income tax on the money you put in.

Let's say you made \$50k last year. We are allowed to make something like \$15k without paying any tax on it, so you would be paying tax on \$35k. If you put \$10k into your RRSP it would lower the amount you'll get taxed on by \$10k so you'll only pay tax on \$25k.

In this account scenarios (1) and (2) described above can happen without you getting taxed as well. However, when you take money out of your RRSP it counts as income. 

As a thought experiment, if you put \$10k into your RRSP this year and took \$10k out next year it would be like you deferred paying tax on that $10k from this year to next. This means in years where you make a lot of money it can be beneficial to put money in an RRSP and then take it out later in years where you don't make anything. 

On top of that, the money in your RRSP can be working for you the whole time it's in there. If you left that \'$10k invested in vun.to for 40 years then when you looked at your account you may be surprised to find \$400k there instead (assuming a 10% increase per year, which is, on average what we see). Yes, this is the power of compounding interest, and why it's important to start this RRSP thing earlier rather than later.

You might not be too worried about paying income tax when you take some of this money out. Even if you get nabbed for 15-25% when you take it out you'll still have lots of money. And if you're really savvy, when you are making no money on paper, then you can take $15k a year out of your RRSP without paying income tax on it. 

There's some maximum you can put into your RRSP each year. It's 18% of your gross income from the year before, plus any bits that you havenm;t used from previous years. And the maximum maximum is like $32k.

---------------
FHSA

This is the most baller of the registered accounts for yourself (though an RESP is even more baller for your kids). It functions like an RRSP, mostly. The big caveat is that when you take money out in order to buy a qualifying home then you don't pay tax on this withdrawl.

So... you don't pay income tax when you put that money into your FHSA, and you don't pay income tax when you take it out. And you can make dividends and capital gains inside the account tax free while you wait. Pretty baller.

The only downside is you can only put $8k in per year to a max of ... $40k currently. If you're thinking about buying a home then this is for sure the first account to put money into.

-----------
RESP

This one is also kinda weird. When you put money into an RESP is doesn't offset your income like an RRSP, and your kid gets taxed when they take it out. However, your kid probably isn't paying income tax anyways since they have so many tuition credits, and aren't making tons of money

Also, the government adds 20% when you put money in. The total the government will add is \$7200 over some number of years (max \$500 per year). That alone will probably make it worth it to have one of these for each kid. Personally, my dad's deal with me was he matched whatever money I put in from my summer jobs. That felt like a cool way to introduce the idea of saving and investing and also to make it a team effort to pay for school.
---------------

Specific info for RRSP season - RRSP catchup loans

Most banks now offer an RRSP catchup line of credit. And this will be even weirder, so lets just do an example.

Like before, you made \$50k last year, \$15k is your tax-free entitlement and say you contributed \$10k to your tax deferred accounts already (say your \$8k max to your FHSA and \$2k to your RRSP). You have no more free cash to contribute to your RRSP, so you would currently be charged tax on \$25k. Having a look at the tax table below we see that the tax rate for income below \$57k is 15%: So we would have to pay 15% of \$25k which is \$6250. For most folks, they have already paid a bunch of tax which was taken off of their paychecks, so they probably get a little bit back such that the total amount they pay is \$6250.

Our bank offers us the option of borrowing \$25k for one year paying 5% interest as an RRSP catchup loan. If we take them up on this, then we put the \$25k into our RRSP, and get the \$6250 back from Canada. We immediately put that toward our loan and then have \$18750 on the loan left. Over the course of one year the 5% interest adds up to about $1000 leading to a loan of \$19.7k. However, our investment of the \$25k has also grown (tax free) at about 10% on average so the \$25k is now worth about \$27.6k.

So, by the end of the year we have a loan of \$19.7k and an investment of \$27.6k. The difference is about \$8k. We are \$8k richer from kind of doing nothing. The only downside is we have to be able to pay off the $19.7k without taking money out of the RRSP. If we can pay off a good chunk during the year and have other access to debt then it's a no brainer - you should definitely take the loan and do this. It's an easy \$8k towards your net worth.

[There's even maybe the possibility of taking the money out of your RRSP, paying tax on it the next year... and then borrowing on an RRSP line of credit again... though this seems a little sketchy to me, and if I were a bank I'd probably be trying to make rules to stop this. if this sounds confusing then just ignore it...]

Tax rateTaxable income threshold
15%on the portion of taxable income that is $57,375 or less, plus
20.5%on the portion of taxable income over $57,375 up to $114,750, plus
26%on the portion of taxable income over $114,750 up to $177,882, plus
29%on the portion of taxable income over $177,882 up to $253,414, plus
33%on the portion of taxable income over $253,414


Comments

Popular posts from this blog

What is debt?

What is risk?