What is debt?
To talk about debt we have to revisit some notions about the stock market and index funds. We know that if you have money, then over time it should make you more money. This is the core tenant of capitalism. There's also a fair passive return we can expect for that money - say 10%. To get a 10% return we have to be open to some risk, but it's really not that risky so long as our time horizon is long.
What I mean is that as long as you're going to have your money invested for 5 to 10 years then you're likely to get a 10% return. Here's the return you would have got if you invested at each year in history:
Investing in index funds not only averages over a large number of business, but buying and holding index funds averages over time as well.
Ok, so back to debt. Debt is the opposite of investing. It's sort of like... someone is investing their money in you. Depending on how risky of an investment you are they'll want a higher or lower payoff. That's why a credit card that is given to almost anyone has a high interest rate and a mortgage has a low one. With a credit card you can just go bankrupt or flee the country and not pay. So they need to charge you more because you are potentially sketchy. With a house, it's harder to run away with all your assets. The bank can just take your house back, so they're not really risking much.
I think of debt as two different things.
What I mean is that as long as you're going to have your money invested for 5 to 10 years then you're likely to get a 10% return. Here's the return you would have got if you invested at each year in history:
It's very spiky. If you invested in some years you could get a 40% return and in others a 30% loss. For instance, the two big down spikes are the great depression and the 2008 financial crisis. Some years would have been good, some bad. What if we average over 2 years?
It's a little less spiky. What if we average over 5 years?
Less spiky. What if we average over 10 years?
Less spiky. 20 years?
So... you get the idea. Averaging over time smoothes out our experience. If we are going to invest for a long time then we are somewhat guaranteed a good time. Even that crappy time at the start (ie the great depression) is eventually smoothed out such that we have positive returns even if we invested at the worst point in history. Investing in index funds not only averages over a large number of business, but buying and holding index funds averages over time as well.
Ok, so back to debt. Debt is the opposite of investing. It's sort of like... someone is investing their money in you. Depending on how risky of an investment you are they'll want a higher or lower payoff. That's why a credit card that is given to almost anyone has a high interest rate and a mortgage has a low one. With a credit card you can just go bankrupt or flee the country and not pay. So they need to charge you more because you are potentially sketchy. With a house, it's harder to run away with all your assets. The bank can just take your house back, so they're not really risking much.
I think of debt as two different things.
(1) Good debt. Borrowing money in order to leverage it for financial/personal benefit.
- If you start a business and need capital to get off the ground, this can be a good reason to borrow money. The interest you pay on the money is an expense of the business. In this case, borrowing money, even at like 12%, can be worthwhile because that money, plus your labour, can be leveraged into something meaningful and/or valuable.
- If you want to buy a house, it is unlikely that you'll be able to do it without borrowing money. In this case the interest you pay can be thought of as a cost of ownership. A house can provide financial incentives versus borrowing, open up the opportunity to rent, and provide stability and meaning. All of which are reasonable reasons to pay interest. Also, mortgages are the only time you'll be able to borrow below prime, since you have lots of collateral so it is not risky for the bank.
- borrowing to top up your RRSP.
(2) Bad debt. Anything you buy just because you want it when you don't have the money right now.
- Buying a car that you can't afford outright is an example of this. Although the calculations involved in comparing a new to a used car can get complicated. If your car has cheap financing (like 0-2%) then mayyyyybe this can be reasonable.
- Buying new clothes on your credit card when you can't pay it off before they accumulate interest.
- eating out at a restaurant when you don't have money in your account and you put it on a credit card instead.
- basically ever using your credit card when you can't pay the balance before it starts accruing 18-22% interest.
If you borrow money for less than 10% then you can just put it in index funds which make 10% and you'll on average make money with no effort.
Mostly you can't get loans for under 10% for this reason.
Mostly you can't get loans for under 10% for this reason.





Comments
Post a Comment