What is an Index Fund? (averaging, index funds, surprisingly simple answers)
Ok, so there's some cool math quirks that I'd like to share with you (not really quirks, more like structural regularities that are beautiful and well understood, but seem cute and amazing). And... if we understand what averaging does then we can understand why diversifying our bets is safe.
We all know what to expect when we plot the heights of 10000 people chosen at random. We have an intuition that some middle height will be the average... lots of folks will be around that height and then heights above and below the average will drop off in frequency, forming the bell-curve thing. "Bell curve" is a thing in our common vernacular, despite it being pretty mathy.
What we're doing is actually a deep result from probability. The height of any one person can be thought of as a random variable [this is rigorously defined, but an intuitive understanding is fine here]. As we take bigger and bigger samples of folks' heights, the average height in our sample will be randomly distributed approximately like a normal distribution (bell curve thing) with the same average as the population and the same standard deviation (how spready-out the bell is). This is called the central-limit theorem, in case ya'll want to track it down for some more rigour.
I'll give you a little real-life tid-bit that can be your next mathy party trick (ok, it's possible I'm not the best at parties). Have you ever been at a fair and seen a "guess how many jelly beans are in the jar" thing? Well, if we look at folks' guesses then they form a bell curve. And you guessed it - the average of the bell curve is the right number.
Somehow, each individual is not particularly good at guessing the right amount, but taken collectively a large number of humans are very good at guessing the right number. This even works in a really weird way. If you want to guess better at these things then do the following: (1) make a first guess; (2) think about it some more (3) make another guess; (4) repeat a bunch (5) average your choices. You'll do better than a 1-off shot.
So, now that you are infinitely more popular at parties which feature a jar of jelly beans (already well-worth the read, I know)... This same principle can also work to provide you with the maximum average return on your invested money while minimizing risk. Sounds pretty good, ya?
We can think of the stocks of publicly traded companies as random variables. If we buy a lot of them, then our average rate of return will be very close to the average rate of return of the economy (around 10%). We could make lots of guesses at what the right bets are and it kind of doesn't matter if we're good at guessing... the average will be close to right.
However, it used to be pretty hard to buy stock in almost everything. Each stock has a fixed price, say like $10, so buying even one of everything ends up being costly. Also, buying and selling an individual stock ends up incurring a prohibitive amount of fees.
So some folks made what are called index funds. With lots of money, they buy up lots of stock in lots of companies and then sell you a share of this whole. Even with a small amount of money you can get maximally diversified and take advantage of the fact that the economy tends to go up by 10% per year. They also have the lowest fees to buy and sell of any financial product.
These index funds also have a self-cleaning feature. If a company starts doing badly... then at some point the index fund will cut it out of the underlying assets and make room for some new company that is doing better. In this way the index ends up keeping more winners than losers.
Ok, so buying these things is probably complicated right? Well, it's actually shockingly easy to set up your own retirement and savings accounts and buy these things in these accounts; especially when compared with finding a financial advisor at the bank, getting them to do a slightly worse option for you and then charging you 2% of your money for the privilege of being separated from control of your own money and security. You get a worse option, less control, more fear, and you pay the bank for the privilege.
How do they get away with it? A large part of the banks' business model is convincing you it's complicated and you should be fearful. They are the experts and you shouldn't try to understand. In fact, most people at the bank have very little education and suffer from the same fear and scarcity mindset.
How do you set up these accounts? Rather than recreating the resource, I'll just point you here: https://www.millennial-revolution.com/investworkshop/
Basically for Canadians:
(1) set up accounts at Questrade.*
(2) buy index funds in these accounts.
*an online place to hold investment accounts including your RRSP, TFSA, FHSA. WealthSimple seems to be offering perhaps an easier onboarding experience and a fsairt balance of pros and cons to Questrade. I'll be moving some money over there, half out of curiosity for the sake of the blog and half because they seem to be offering incentives to move your RRSP's there to the tune of 2%.
JL Collins is sort of like the cool old uncle of the financial independence movement. He wrote a book for his grand-daughter, called "The Simple Path to Wealth." His advice: just buy an index that tracks the US economy like VTI (or sold on the Canadian stock exchange as vun.to). It includes businesses that are globally distributed (like google and apple) so you're actually exposed to global diversity anyways.
The Millenium Revolution thing is a little more involved, and teaches you a bit about bonds (which math says can stabilize your investments without sacrificing average return if they make up 10% or so of your money). And buying a few other index funds. Truth is... the more complicated you make things the more likely you are to get overwhelmed and ditch the whole thing.
Like many things in life, there are diminishing returns for how much value you get from additional effort. Buying VTI is the equivalent to doing 30 min of walking a day. It is so much better than doing nothing for your physical health. The next 30 min of activity can't really compete with the gains of the first 30. Additionally, if you think you have to do something very hard and complicated for your health you might get overwhelmed and do nothing. Doing no physical activity slowly erodes your health. Doing nothing with your money slowly erodes your financial health at a rate of 3% inflation.
There will always be ways to improve your investment situation with more effort. Personally, I don't like spending time dealing with investments. For me, I feel secure with knowing I'm doing pretty close to the best thing with my money, and I can spend almost all of my time doing whatever I want. So our goal here is to get you walking 30 min a day - just the most bang-for-your-buck relationship with investing. And it turns out that most people that muck around more than the minimum end up shooting themselves in the foot anyhow. The more you poke around the more likely your fear and or greed will get the better of you.
It's very intoxicating to believe that you know something that everyone else does not. Humans are pattern recognition machines, and we get joy out of finding patterns (ever when none are there). It was better in our evolutionary history to err on the side of seeing too many patterns, rather than not catching the ones that are there. And the stock market is just a complex system that our pattern recognition parts did not evolve with. The stock market is very unlike the regular movements of a wildebeast that we might wanna eat, or a lion that might want to eat us. So to protect ourselves from ourselves we should just jam money into index funds and forget about it.
In a cute confirmation of this... people who hold VTI end up doing worse than the fund on average. Why? Well, they can't help themselves... when it goes up they think they can time the market and sell, and then when it dips they think they can buy at the right time. Sometimes, they behave even worse... when it dips they get scared and sell... and when it goes up they get greedy and buy in. So even though we know that we're supposed to buy and hold the index forever... we can't help ourselves. We mess around and get burned. No one knows how to time the market (expect folks like Elon and other insider traders that have such a big effect on the market they can change it themselves and then benefit from the changes).
In summary:
(1) averaging is stabilizing
(2) somebody made financial products that takes advantage of averaging (index funds)
(3) you should buy them and forget about it
(4) you put these can index funds into registered accounts (TFSA, RRSP, FHSA)
(5) you can do this all by yourself at Questrade
(6) then you get to carry on with whatever you care about in your life, rather than spending your life in fear or greed around money.
(7) fuck banks
Comments
Post a Comment