What is a stock?
Before we talk about what a stock is we need to talk about what a business is.
If I'm a handyman and I get contracts on my own, own all my own tools, and go out everyday and do some Reno's for folks, do I have a business? Perhaps I have a job.
One of the thought experiments to see if I have a business or a job, or both, is to ask - what happens if I step away from the business for a day, a week, a year? Can I hire someone to do the parts of it that are necessary to make it run day to day?
If I'm the only employee of my reno business then I can't walk away and have it run. What I own is mostly a job. If instead I hire out the work itself, hire out the finding of contracts and quoting, in fact, hire out all the labour, then what I have left is a business. I own the means of production, the relationships with employees and customers and distributors of materials, and my name recognition and reputation. After hiring out all the labour, if the business still makes money then it is a profitable business. If I can't do this then I have both a business and an obligatory job.
This is said with no judgement. A job can be lovely, and getting to create your own job increases the chances that it can be lovely.
But a business is something else. When I create a business I create a thing that generates value even in my absence. My capital is valued instead of my labour. Over time, this capital makes more money which can be reinvested into the business to increase capital, or used to fund a life. A business is a value creating machine, and as such is something that you can sell.
Some businesses get very big. Big in the sense of both a large amount of capital is involved and big in terms of how much profit the business generates above and beyond its costs. When one person owns such a thing they might want to sell it - but to do so to one other person becomes unwieldy. It's just too expensive. Instead, that person can decide to divide the company up into bits that are easier for one person to buy. A single person can now own a bit of the value creating machine, and share in the profits. The person may also be included in how the machine is run, but perhaps they don't even want to be.
These bits are called shares or stocks. Some shares are voting shares (the person gets a vote in how things are run) but most common ones are not. The shareholder is simply along for the ride. This is now a publicly owned company.
When a publicly owned company makes profits that exceed all their costs, that money is given out to the owners of the company (the shareholders). These distributions of money are called dividends.
And how much does a share cost? Well it depends on how well the company is doing - maybe they are making lots of excess money and paying out good dividends - and it also depends on how well we think that company will do in the future.
If I bought into a company early, perhaps a share was not so expensive because the company was still learning how to make profit and folks didn't trust them to be able to do it in the future. A year later, that company has figured out better ways to make money, maybe expanded their business and folks now think very highly of them. My share might be worth 10 times what I bought it for. Conversely, in trying to expand the company it may have crashed and burned. My share may be worth 1/10 of what I bought it for. If I sell in either scenario I have a very different amount of money than I did a year ago (and I also have some from dividends).
Buying a share is half like owning a value making machine and half like making a bet on the future of that machine. As such, bets are risky. Too risky, in fact. There are variables way outside our control or foresight. Buying individual stocks is a very unusual thing to do from a risk reward perspective but it nevertheless seems like a thing that compels many. They are mostly driven by greed and an overconfidence in their abilities to know the future.
This overconfidence is rewarded in our evolutionary history (especially for males and especially as they enter breeding age). However, the stock market is very different from the environment where these behaviours evolved. More on risk here (link to risk article).
So if we're not going to buy individual stocks, then can we be involved in the stock market? The short answer is yes and it's because of the moderating effect of averages, and the fact that unprofitable businesses die and make way for businesses that are better able to compete. Competition and simple averaging allow us a minimally risky average return of 10% per year, the growth rate of the economy at large.
Anything that promises a return above 10% is lying (they hope it will return more) and they are praying on your greed. Anything that returns less than 10% (like a GIC) will turn around and use your money to make more money. They are praying on your fear.
10% is fair. Notably, this is more than 3% inflation. Your reward for managing fear and greed is your money makes more money, instead of slowly losing 3% per year in your bank account.
How to buy this magical average of the stocks? Well it turns out it's super easy and I'll tell you all about it. Next article we'll talk about averaging and why it works.
Comments
Post a Comment