Math, money, motivations

One of my earliest memories I have about money was my dad complaining about my uncle. My uncle regularly picked up a copy of the local paper from work after someone else was done reading it. My dad paid for his instead. I remember my dad saying: "How fucking cheap can you be?" I didn't understand why it made him so angry, or why it made him disparage my uncle. 

My dad worked a middle class job as an electrician for General Motors. He made enough to support a family of three kids off one income. We didn't want for food or shelter. We got to go camping for two weeks every summer. We played soccer and had music lessons and generally had a pretty privileged life. On the other hand, my uncle worked as an architect and my aunt as an optometrist. They had financial means well in excess of our household. But it wasn't just income that was different, it was their relationship to money. 

To my dad it was shameful to get the free version of the thing instead of paying. Paying for the paper is what you were supposed to do. It's what good citizens do. If he was caught taking a paper home from work instead of paying for it he would have been deeply embarrassed. To him, being able to buy the paper was proof that he was doing what he was supposed to do - earn money to support his family. Money was supposed to be spent. That's what you went to work for.

Saving a couple dollars every week was not just cheap, but greedy. How much money did you really need? My uncle and aunt combined made so much more than my dad alone. Surely if he paid for the paper they should too. To my dad money was meant for spending. This is aligned with the working class view of money.

But it wasn't just the paper. It was a coffee bought at work instead of bringing his own in a thermos. It was figuring out how to contribute to his RRSP such that he paid less tax. It was finding the little strategies here and there to save money. My dad couldn't learn any of these things because he was ashamed that he didn't know. 

You know who else feels shame around money? Almost every one else in the working class. Perhaps this is actually the defining feature of the working class.

How is it that when a working class person wins the lottery they often have no money after 10 years (not to mention their life being worse)? Giving someone money doesn't change their class or their relationship to money. In fact, it's pretty hard to change class no matter what you do. Pro sports athletes start making an incredible sum, only to be bereft shortly after their career ends. You can have a million dollars in your bank account and still be working class. You can work a menial job and have an upper class relationship with money (The Wealthy Barber expresses this sentiment, and was a great read as a kid).

For the upper middle class, money starts to represent something other than for spending - money saved can be put to work. Money saved is capital. What it means to live in a capitalist society is that we value capital over income (though the explanation of what this means is a long rabbit hole that stretches back centuries).

Who benefits from the working class feeling shame and fear around money? The upper class of course. As long as the working class fears money and conceives of it as a thing to spend, then the people with capital  will profit. And wealth disparity grows larger still. 

The richest folks are also men. Men prevented women from finding equality in power a number of ways. One method of coercive control of women was, and is, financial abuse. Men benefit from women being financially in the dark. Financial literacy is another way to fight the patriarchy. 

The goal of this writing, and attendant workshop, is to set up a space where you feel safe enough to explore your relationship to money. However, in our way is a wall of shame. Shame is a pretty terrible state to be in for learning. So, we take care of our nervous systems. We're going to build an environment where it's safe to play with money, with the idea of money, and we're going to get curious about our feelings about money, our feelings about risk, value, security, community, and so on. 

Why do I think we can do this? It's the same approach I use to teach math. Incidentally, nobody thinks math is fun either, but I've committed myself to a life where I fight that little battle. I also happen to really enjoy teaching math, and find it moving to witness someone be brave in the face of a scary thing. I'm honoured when someone trusts me enough to do this with me. We also need some simple math in our pursuit of understanding money... so we've got some synergy. We've got to battle the same shame dragons to learn math and money. May as well slay them together.

I can also commit to one somewhat motivating claim: the intellectual component of this will be much easier than you think. Unfortunately, the emotional component of this will be much harder than you think. With that in mind, we're always going to be on the lookout for statements like: "why can't I do this?" What we're endeavouring to do is hard, just not for the reasons it seems like it should be. If you're willing to be brave and engage with the scary thing, I promise it's worth it.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

What is an RRSP, TFSA, FHSA, RESP?

What is debt?

What is risk?